Pipe-organ.wiki:Composition list style guide - Revision history

Fiskfan1999: /* Contents */

2023-09-18T14:23:01Z

Contents

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:23, 18 September 2023
Line 23:		Line 23:
	The names of individual movements should go in the '''incipits''' column separated by line breaks<ref>The adventurous user may find themselves compelled to refactor the table in such a way that each movement within the '''incipits''' column is a separate row and all the other columns are stretched using ''rowspan''. Please do not do this, there is no point, and it would be unnecessarily difficult to refactor these tables in the future.</ref>. This will lead to a nice structured view between the title and the individual movements (and their incipits).		The names of individual movements should go in the '''incipits''' column separated by line breaks<ref>The adventurous user may find themselves compelled to refactor the table in such a way that each movement within the '''incipits''' column is a separate row and all the other columns are stretched using ''rowspan''. Please do not do this, there is no point, and it would be unnecessarily difficult to refactor these tables in the future.</ref>. This will lead to a nice structured view between the title and the individual movements (and their incipits).

	The reference should be a valid piece of literature that points to the existence of this piece. For example, a book which lists this composition, or an article or other piece of information about it.		The reference should be a valid piece of literature that points to the existence of this piece. For example, a book which lists this composition, or an article or other piece of information about it. ''Note:'' You '''should''' use a <nowiki><ref></ref></nowiki> block to write the reference instead of just writing it inline so that it does not take up too much space.

	=== Other additions ===		=== Other additions ===

Fiskfan1999: /* About Incipits */

2023-09-18T02:31:35Z

About Incipits

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:31, 17 September 2023
Line 60:		Line 60:

	===About Incipits ===		===About Incipits ===
	It is possible that the reference for a piece of music does not include the score (for example, if it is from a list of compositions such as [[Repertorium Orgelmusik]]). In this case, you can find the score mentioned (according to the '''Published''' column) and write the incipit based on that. In this case, you do not have to make another reference in the '''Reference''' column mentioning that this is from the score. Hopefully this fact would be self-evident.		It is possible that the reference for a piece of music does not include the score (for example, if it is from a list of compositions such as [[Repertorium Orgelmusik]]). In this case, you can find the score mentioned (according to the '''Published''' column) and write the incipit based on that. In this case, you do not have to make another reference in the '''Reference''' column mentioning that this is from the score. Hopefully this fact would be self-evident (especially for people verifying this information).

	== Examples ==		== Examples ==

Fiskfan1999 at 02:13, 18 September 2023

2023-09-18T02:13:35Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:13, 17 September 2023
Line 97:		Line 97:
	=== Other ===		=== Other ===
	For a composer which fits both of these categories (such as an early composer with some published works and others in copies), it may be a good idea to have both types of tables instead of trying to combine them into one.		For a composer which fits both of these categories (such as an early composer with some published works and others in copies), it may be a good idea to have both types of tables instead of trying to combine them into one.

			== Conclusion ==
			One of the main reasons that I switched from wvlist (my own website which functioned only as a list of compositions, but was more rigid) to a Mediawiki page is that it allows us to be more flexible with how we display information. However, following these guidelines (which will not cause any problems for more than 99% of composers) will keep a unified feel and help present information in an efficient way. In my opinion, this is the best balance of what information can be concisely presented in a table and what would be better off in writing before or after the table.

	== Notes ==		== Notes ==
	[[File:Allemagne timbre HugoDistler 1992obl.jpg\|thumb\|[[Hugo Distler]]]]		[[File:Allemagne timbre HugoDistler 1992obl.jpg\|thumb\|[[Hugo Distler]]]]
	<references />		<references />

Fiskfan1999 at 02:03, 18 September 2023

2023-09-18T02:03:41Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:03, 17 September 2023
Line 1:		Line 1:
			[[File:Lili Boulanger - photographie Henri Manuel.jpg\|thumb\|[[Lili Boulanger]]]]
	The following is a guide for recommending how to create a list of compositions for a composer.		The following is a guide for recommending how to create a list of compositions for a composer.

Line 98:		Line 99:

	== Notes ==		== Notes ==
			[[File:Allemagne timbre HugoDistler 1992obl.jpg\|thumb\|[[Hugo Distler]]]]
	<references />		<references />

Fiskfan1999 at 01:56, 18 September 2023

2023-09-18T01:56:24Z

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 The following is a guide for recommending how to create a list of compositions for a composer.
-== Notes ==
+== Caution ==
 '''This article is written by William and the future administrators of pipe-organ.wiki and is protected. It does not adhere to the reference-based style of the rest of the wiki but instead contains our original thoughts about how composition tables should be created.'''
@@ Line 8: / Line 8: @@
 == See also ==
 * [[Pipe-organ.wiki:Incipits style guide]]
 == Examples ==
@@ Line 44: / Line 96: @@
 === Other ===
 For a composer which fits both of these categories (such as an early composer with some published works and others in copies), it may be a good idea to have both types of tables instead of trying to combine them into one.

Fiskfan1999: Fiskfan1999 moved page Pipe-organ.wiki:Composition List Guide to Pipe-organ.wiki:Composition list style guide

2023-09-17T23:15:40Z

Fiskfan1999 moved page Pipe-organ.wiki:Composition List Guide to Pipe-organ.wiki:Composition list style guide

← Older revision	Revision as of 19:15, 17 September 2023
(No difference)

Fiskfan1999: Protected "Pipe-organ.wiki:Composition List Guide": High traffic page ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite))

2023-09-17T23:14:55Z

Protected "Pipe-organ.wiki:Composition List Guide": High traffic page ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite))

← Older revision	Revision as of 19:14, 17 September 2023
(No difference)

Fiskfan1999: Created page with "The following is a guide for recommending how to create a list of compositions for a composer. == Notes == '''This article is written by William and the future administrators of pipe-organ.wiki and is protected. It does not adhere to the reference-based style of the rest of the wiki but instead contains our original thoughts about how composition tables should be created.''' This article contains examples of composition lists from real composers. They have been edited..."

2023-09-17T23:14:47Z

Created page with "The following is a guide for recommending how to create a list of compositions for a composer. == Notes == '''This article is written by William and the future administrators of pipe-organ.wiki and is protected. It does not adhere to the reference-based style of the rest of the wiki but instead contains our original thoughts about how composition tables should be created.''' This article contains examples of composition lists from real composers. They have been edited..."

New page

The following is a guide for recommending how to create a list of compositions for a composer.

== Notes ==
'''This article is written by William and the future administrators of pipe-organ.wiki and is protected. It does not adhere to the reference-based style of the rest of the wiki but instead contains our original thoughts about how composition tables should be created.'''

This article contains examples of composition lists from real composers. They have been edited for brevity and the references have been removed to not clutter this article's references list. Refer to the articles about these composers for a more up-to-date composition list with references.

== See also ==
* [[Pipe-organ.wiki:Incipits style guide]]

== Examples ==
The following are a few small and basic examples of how to style your composition list.

=== Early Music ===
For early music composers, especially those where there are not many works published by them and most works survive in handwritten copies, a table that includes the sources themselves may be the best option.

{| class="wikitable"
|+ Organ works by [[Arnold Matthias Brunckhorst]]
|-
! Source !! Title !! Incipit !! Notes !! ref.
|-
| [[D-LEm Becker II.2.51]] part 5, p.16-19 || Praeludium / ex E. m. / A. m. Brunckhorst || Prelude <score>\relative e'' { e16 g fis e dis cis b a g a b a g }</score> Fugue <score>\relative e' { \time 4/2 r8 e g e b'4 c b g a b }</score> || || ''ref...''
|-
| [[D-B Mus.ms. 30381]] No 4 || Praludium con Fuga. ex G b. / pedaliter. / di / Mons: Prunth. || Prelude <score>\relative g'' { \key g \minor r16 g fis g d g fis g c, g' fis g bes, }</score> Fugue <score>\relative g' { \key g \minor r8 g bes c d d d d | bes8. a16 g8 }</score> || ''di: Job: Ringk.'' Speculative, also attributed to [[Nicolaus Bruhns]] || ''ref...''
|}

=== Modern Music ===
For modern composers who have published most of their works, a table including the year composed or opus number (if available) would be a good option.

{| class="wikitable"
|+ Organ Works by [[Maurice Duruflé]]
|-
! Op. !! Title !! Incipit !! Notes !! Published !! Ref.
|-
| 2 || Scherzo || <score><< \relative g { \key f \minor \time 3/4 \clef bass <g a e'>2 <e g a>4~2 <g a e'>4 } \\ \relative g, { <g c>2.~2.\laissezVibrer } >></score> || || Durand || ''ref...''
|-
| 7 || Prélude et Fugue sur le Nom d' [[Jehan Alain|Alain]] || Prélude <score><< \relative a { \time 2/2 \key d \minor \tuplet 3/2 4 { \clef bass a8 d a a f' a, a bes a } } \\ \relative d, { \tuplet 3/2 { <d a' d>8 r8 r8 } r4 r4 } >></score> Fugue <score>\relative a { \clef alto \time 6/8 a8 d a a f' a, a bes a g }</score> || <score>\new Staff \with { \omit TimeSignature } \relative a' { \time 5/4 \stemDown a4^"A" d^"L" a^"A" a^"I" f'^"N" \bar "" }</score> || Durand || ''ref...''
|-
| 12 || Fugue sur le theme du Carillon des heures de la Cathédrale de Soissons || <score><< \relative g' { \clef bass \time 6/8 \partial 8 g8 e4 g8 d4 g8 c,4 b8 e4 e,8 } \\ \relative a, { r8 a2.~2.\laissezVibrer } \\ \\ \relative c' { r8 c4. b a g } >></score> || || Orgue&L 48 (1962) L'Organiste 50 (1962) || ''ref...''
|-
| || Méditation || <score><< \relative ees'' { \key c \minor \time 2/2 ees8 d c4~8 d ees f ges f ees4 } \\ \relative c' { <c g'>2 <f a> <ees bes'> } >></score> || Written in 1964 || Durand 15470 (2001) || ''ref...''
|}

=== Other ===
For a composer which fits both of these categories (such as an early composer with some published works and others in copies), it may be a good idea to have both types of tables instead of trying to combine them into one.